The International Conference of Undergraduate Research
  • Home
  • About
    • About ICUR
    • ICUR Philosophy
    • Participating Institutions
    • Monash Warwick Alliance
  • ICUR This Year
  • FAQ
  • Resource Hub
    • Online Training Sessions
    • Resources for Students
    • Resources for Institutions
  • Resources
    • Writing an Abstract
    • Preparing Your Abstract Training
    • Impact Blog
    • Spoken Presentations
    • Poster Presentations
    • Conference Participation Guide
    • Technical Specification
  • Organising Committees
  • Impact Blog
  • Past events
    • ICUR 2026
    • ICUR 2025
    • ICUR 2024
    • ICUR 2022
    • ICUR 2021
    • ICUR 2020
    • ICUR 2019
    • ICUR 2018
    • ICUR 2017
    • ICUR 2016
    • ICUR 2015
    • ICUR 2014
    • ICUR 2013
The International Conference of Undergraduate Research

Undergraduate research on the global stage

Addressing Feedback for Revise and Resubmit

Find what you need!

  1. What does Revise and Resubmit mean?
  2. Where should I start?
  3. How do I address the suggestions?
  4. My reviewers have mentioned interdisciplinary audiences. What should I do?
  5. My reviewers have different opinions. What should I do?
  6. My reviewer has given “requires improvement” in a category but hasn’t provided feedback on how it can be improved. What should I do?
  7. Do I have to do everything the reviewers have suggested?
  8. How do I know that my revisions will be accepted?

Having your work reviewed by peers in your subject is an important part of academia, both for written and conference submissions. It provides you with the opportunity to refine your work based on constructive feedback from the people that your research is aimed at. For ICUR, as an interdisciplinary conference, we have a diverse panel of reviewers that includes students, academics, and staff from across the world.

A revise and resubmit outcome doesn’t mean that the reviewers don’t think that the research is valuable; only that it could be conveyed better through your abstract to engage people at the conference and encourage them to attend your talk. Reviewers give comments to all submitters (including those who have been accepted) with the aim of being supportive and will often point out parts of the abstract that didn’t make sense on first reading.

Revise and Resubmit IS…

  • a very common outcome – usually around 2/3 of ICUR submitters are asked to make at least some revisions to their abstract before they are accepted to present.
  • based on reviewers’ knowledge, interpretation, and expertise – our conference audience (presenters and attendees) is made up of people with different areas of expertise, different base knowledge, and different cultural and academic frames of reference. Similarly, our review panel is both international and interdisciplinary!
  • supportive and developmental – engaging with and learning from different people’s feedback will help you reframe your work for specialist and non-specialist audiences alike.

Revise and Resubmit IS NOT…

  • a judgment on the value, rigour, or significance of your research project – the ICUR review panel are assessing how you communicate your research, not your research itself.

It sounds obvious – but your first action should be to read and think about your review feedback.

Your reviewers will have highlighted where they think your abstract might benefit from some changes, either in their Comments to Submitter or in their in line comments (annotations on your abstract). You might find it helpful to break these down into bullet points – make a list of what each reviewer has actually suggested. Have they identified the same things? Do any of their comments contradict each other?* Do you understand what they’re asking you to do?

*The ICUR Abstract Review process is double-blind and completed independently (reviewers do not converse with each other when assessing). As above, it’s also completed by an interdisciplinary panel – so each reviewer is approaching abstracts from their own perspective, background, and knowledge base (just like the audience will)! This means that it’s not uncommon to receive reviews which look like they contradict each other. If this is the case for you, don’t panic – jump to here for some advice on this.

This is a difficult question, as it will really depend on the feedback. Some reviewers will give you very clear instructions on how to revise your abstract, but others may have been a bit more general in their advice. For ICUR specifically, you may find the following useful:

  • Reacquaint yourself with the ICUR abstract rubric – you can find this in our Resources for Students. Reviewers have used this to evaluate whether your abstract is currently suitable for ICUR, so remind yourself of the key information you’ve been asked to include.
  • Consider your audience – if you’ve been advised that your abstract isn’t suitable for interdisciplinary audiences, consider reading our Adapting Your Abstract guide. It might be useful to share your abstract with a non-specialist friend or family member too – the more feedback you can get, the better!
  • Think about how you’re using your word count – ICUR abstracts are only 250 words or fewer. It’s not a lot of space! Remember that your abstract is like an advert or an elevator pitch – its purpose is to intrigue audience members enough that they will want to learn more by coming to your presentation (where you’ll be able to share much more detail). What information do you think really needs to be included right now, and what could wait until the presentation itself (or be omitted completely)?

The most common feedback authors receive is regarding the accessibility of their abstract to an interdisciplinary audience. This is absolutely the most challenging part of applying to ICUR and is what makes this conference unique. We have put together an entire guide about revisions you can make to help your abstract here.

As all our reviewers come from different backgrounds and disciplines, it is natural for some reviews to conflict with each other. It is common that something might be confusing to one reviewer while being succinct to another! As an interdisciplinary conference, your abstract for ICUR should be accessible to everyone, which includes your reviewers. If something has been commented on, then it is best to take the time to think how it might be changed for clarity.

Sometimes reviewers can give completely opposite feedback, something that is very common in academia! The best advice here is to try and reword parts of your abstract in a new way, often a different perspective entirely might be the best way to engage the broadest audience. If you would like an extra pair of eyes then you are more than welcome to contact the ICUR team at icurstudents@warwick.ac.uk or come to one of our training sessions.

This can be frustrating, but do check that the reviewer hasn’t provided clarification the inline or paragraph comments. An important question to consider in this case is what you would do to improve, can you make it clearer or more perhaps give an example to support the section? It can also be helpful to remind yourself of all the components that should be included in abstract, which can be found here.

The “revise and resubmit” process is not just a hurdle to overcome for the conference, but an important part of academic writing and development. Engaging with reviewer feedback allows you to refine your ideas and enhance the clarity of your work, which will also help you to develop a more engaging and effective presentation for the conference. By taking on board early feedback you can see what components of your research may require more time to explain and explore ways you might be able to do this.

No!

Well, not necessarily.

As above, there are circumstances in which you might feel that a reviewer’s suggestion is not appropriate. For example, a reviewer might have asked you to include some information to which you don’t have access or which you don’t think is relevant; or you might think they missed something when they were reading your abstract. This is okay – reviewers are approaching abstracts from their own perspectives, and sometimes they might miss something! If you really don’t agree with a comment, you don’t have to do anything with it. You’re the expert on your work.

However – all feedback is valuable. Audiences want to feel interested and included in the presentations they watch, and we want you to be able to share your research with as many people as possible – so communication (and feedback about how you’re communicating) is key! In the second review, we’ll be looking to see that you have engaged with the feedback you received and adapted your abstract accordingly, even if you haven’t used every suggestion.

This is a really tricky question to help with, but the main thing we can recommend is reading over the revised abstract and thinking if it addresses the bulk of the reviewer feedback. Things like grammatical and spelling errors can be easily picked up and help make sure your abstract is ready for publication in the conference program. Getting feedback from other people is also really helpful – if your grandparents or friends can understand your abstract then it’s very likely the reviewer will also! If you want further feedback on your revisions then you are more than welcome to reach out to the ICUR team who can give you an idea of whether you have addressed the given feedback.

Copyright © ICUR 2026

‹ › ×

    ‹ › ×